Editorial and Fact-Checking Policy

Adherence to Academic Standards in Islamic Research

To guarantee the Expertise and Trustworthiness necessary for an academic platform, Mizanul Muslimin operates under a stringent Editorial and Fact-Checking Policy, ensuring all published Islamic Information meets disciplinary standards.

1. Expertise and Principal Investigator Review

All content undergoes a mandatory peer review process led by accredited scholars:

Principal Investigator: Editorial direction and final content approval are conducted by Akhmad Syafiuddin, a recognized expert in Islamic discourse and law, holding academic credentials from Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt. This background ensures the content possesses a high degree of jurisprudential and doctrinal authority.
Doctrinal Coherence: Content is critically reviewed for its adherence to mainstream Islamic theological and legal methodologies, preventing the propagation of information that deviates from established scholarly consensus (Ijma').

2. Scholarly Verification Protocol

Our verification process is systematic and evidence-based, aligning with research publication standards:

Canonical Source Mandate: Every claim, legal premise, or theological proposition must be supported by direct, verifiable citation from the canonical primary Islamic resources (Qur'an and Sunnah).
Reference Integrity: Citations of Hadith are subject to rigorous Isnad (chain of narration) verification, using established 'Ulum al-Hadith criteria. Only authentic (Sahih/Hasan) narrations are permissible as legal evidence.
Non-Sectarian Presentation: Research is presented objectively. Where scholarly divergence exists (Khilaf), the material details the various arguments and the textual basis (dalil) for each, allowing readers to conduct their own informed analysis.