Why Did Allah Command the Hijab? An Educational Insight into Modesty

Why did Allah command the hijab? According to Islamic teachings, the hijab was commanded as a means to preserve dignity, protect personal boundaries, and foster a society based on modesty and mutual respect. The Qur'an presents this directive in specific verses, particularly Surah An-Nur (24:31) and Surah Al-Ahzab (33:59), which emphasize the importance of modest appearance and conduct for believing women. Hijab is not simply a garment—it is a part of a wider ethical framework that encourages awareness of one's behavior and interaction within society. This introduction explores the deeper rationale behind the divine command, addressing both its religious and societal implications through a juristic lens. For a general overview, see: Understanding the Significance of the Hijab in Islam.

Hijab in Islam is often misunderstood as an isolated rule, disconnected from broader values. However, it is actually a practical extension of the Qur'anic emphasis on modesty (haya')—a value that applies to both men and women. The directive to cover one's adornment is not rooted in shame or suppression but in the preservation of personal honor and ethical boundaries. In this context, hijab functions as a form of visible modesty that aligns with inner dignity.

It is important to recognize that Allah's commandments in the Qur'an are never without purpose. The obligation of hijab carries legal weight in Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), where scholars have categorized it as fardh (obligatory) for adult Muslim women in the presence of non-mahram men. This classification is not only based on scriptural text but also on the objectives of Shariah (maqāṣid al-sharī'ah), which include the protection of honor ('ird) and the prevention of social harm.

Modern readers may struggle to connect religious obligations with personal freedom. Yet, within the Islamic framework, true liberation lies in following divine guidance that upholds human dignity while offering practical solutions for living ethically in diverse societies. This article will unpack the layered wisdom behind the hijab command, drawing from Qur'anic interpretation, juristic opinions, and relevant social perspectives. Whether one is new to Islamic teachings or seeking a deeper understanding, this insight aims to present the hijab not as a restriction—but as a principled, dignified form of presence rooted in clarity, not compulsion.

Hijab in the Context of Revelation

The command for Muslim women to wear the hijab did not arise in isolation—it was revealed during a specific period in Islamic history marked by social change, evolving norms, and the need to establish a clear moral framework. Understanding the context in which Allah commanded the hijab allows us to appreciate its function as more than just a garment—it was part of a broader message about behavior, identity, and mutual respect. In this section, we will delve into the historical and cultural backdrop of early Islam and analyze how the Qur'anic instruction in Surah Al-Ahzab shaped and defined the practice of hijab for generations to come.

Historical and Cultural Background

The hijab was introduced into a world where modesty was interpreted through a tribal, class-based, and often patriarchal lens. Pre-Islamic Arabia—referred to as the Jahiliyyah (Era of Ignorance)—held certain customs that directly conflicted with the values Islam sought to promote.

Contextual Overview

• Women in pre-Islamic Arabia often faced exploitation and lacked legal protections.
• Female dress codes varied based on social status: noble women sometimes covered, while enslaved women were often exposed.
• Public harassment and lack of social boundaries between genders were widespread.

Islamic Reform Through Revelation

Islam's arrival reshaped norms through a lens of accountability, modesty, and justice for all, regardless of class. The hijab was part of that broader reform, signaling dignity and protection for believing women while transforming societal expectations.

Key Social Shifts Introduced

1. Class distinctions were minimized – Modesty became a sign of faith, not wealth or lineage.
2. Public behavior was regulated – Clear boundaries were drawn between unrelated men and women.
3. Women's dignity was legally and socially uplifted – The Qur'an introduced explicit commands to protect women from verbal abuse and objectification.

Scholarly Insights

• Imam al-Tabari emphasized that hijab laws emerged from societal needs, especially after Islam expanded and public interaction increased.
• Imam al-Qurtubi noted that the hijab served as a visible identity marker for believing women, protecting them from being mistaken for others in public spaces.

Revelation Context in Surah Al-Ahzab

The clearest command regarding hijab is found in Surah Al-Ahzab (33:59). This verse was revealed in Medina, a time when the Muslim community had grown, and public interaction between men and women had increased.

The Verse

"O Prophet, tell your wives, your daughters, and the believing women to draw their cloaks (jalabibihinna) over themselves. That is better so they may be recognized and not abused. And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful."

(Surah Al-Ahzab, 33:59)

Explanation of Key Terms

• "Jalabibihinna" refers to the outer garment that covers the body from head to toe.
• "Yu'rafna" (so they may be recognized) emphasizes that hijab serves as a symbol of faith and societal recognition.
• "Fala yu'dhayna" (not abused) indicates hijab is a protection against harassment or mistreatment.

Purpose Embedded in the Verse

1. Identity: To visibly distinguish Muslim women as followers of Islam.
2. Safety: To shield women from harassment, especially during travel or public interaction.
3. Obedience to Allah: To align with the broader framework of Islamic teachings on modesty and conduct.

Chronological Timing

• Surah Al-Ahzab was revealed during the 5th year after Hijrah, a time when Medina had become the political and religious center of Islam.
• This period marked the development of more formal legal rulings, including social interactions, marriage, warfare, and modesty.

Interpretation by Classical Scholars

• Ibn Kathir: This verse was revealed after Muslim women complained of harassment when going out, even though they were dressed modestly.
• Ash-Shawkani: Clarifies that the cloak was meant to prevent misidentification and ensure security in public domains.

Summary of Revelation Context

Element	Explanation	Relevance to Hijab
Historical Setting	Pre-Islamic Arabia with minimal protection for women	Hijab offered social and moral reform
Verse of Revelation	Surah Al-Ahzab, 33:59	Direct command regarding outer garments (jalabib)
Purpose in Verse	To distinguish believing women and prevent abuse	Hijab as protection and identity
Interpretation	Scholars explain it was revealed in response to real-life events	Reinforces practical and ethical reasons
Time of Revelation	5 AH, in Medina	Legal and societal frameworks being established

The Objectives (Maqasid) of Hijab in Sharia

The Islamic legal framework (Sharia) operates upon a set of overarching goals known as Maqasid ash-Shariah, which are designed to protect essential human interests. Hijab, as prescribed in the Qur'an and Hadith, is not a standalone ruling but a command rooted in these higher objectives. Understanding hijab through the lens of Maqasid provides clarity on why it was legislated, how it aligns with the values of dignity and morality, and how it serves as a safeguard in the context of gender relations. This section explores how hijab fulfills key Sharia goals by preserving human dignity and regulating ethical boundaries between genders.

Preservation of Dignity and Morality

In Sharia, one of the core objectives is the preservation of honor (al-'ird) and morality (al-akhlāq). The hijab plays a central role in safeguarding both.

Moral Framework in Islam

Islam encourages modesty in behavior, speech, and attire for both men and women. The hijab is a practical manifestation of this value for women. It is not merely about covering the body, but about preserving one's conduct, self-worth, and social integrity.

How Hijab Protects Dignity and Morality

1. Visual Modesty: Hijab prevents objectification and promotes respect in public interactions.
2. Behavioral Impact: It encourages women to embody modest behavior in line with Islamic ethics.
3. Discouragement of Vanity: Hijab shifts focus from physical appearance to inner character and intellect.
4. Public Safety: Reduces exposure to unwelcome attention or harassment, especially in public spaces.

Scholarly Opinions

• Imam Ibn al-Qayyim asserted that hijab upholds a woman's honor, shielding her from the harms of immodest exposure.
• Imam al-Ghazali linked the hijab with the preservation of khuluq hasan (good character), noting that it fosters societal decency.

Evidence from the Qur'an

Surah An-Nur (24:30–31) not only commands covering but emphasizes lowering the gaze, showing that modesty is a holistic value—not just a dress code.

Gender Interaction Boundaries

Another essential goal of Sharia is to regulate social interactions between men and women to protect the integrity of the family and community. Hijab is one component within a broader framework that outlines ethical gender boundaries.

Why Gender Boundaries Matter

• Islam acknowledges natural attraction between the sexes, but sets boundaries to prevent social corruption (fasād) and emotional entanglements outside of marriage.
• Gender interaction in Islam is not forbidden but structured—based on purpose, necessity, and decorum.

Hijab's Role in Regulating Interactions

1. Visual Separation: Hijab creates a symbolic and physical barrier that minimizes inappropriate gaze or flirtation.
2. Discouraging Unlawful Desire: Prevents casual or suggestive encounters that could lead to fitnah (temptation).
3. Respectful Communication: Encourages professional and respectful dialogue without physical or emotional overfamiliarity.
4. Moral Discipline: Serves as a reminder for both genders to maintain their modesty.

Key Textual Evidence

• Surah Al-Ahzab (33:53): "...And when you ask them (the Prophet's wives) for something, ask them from behind a curtain..."
• This verse is part of the foundational basis for gender separation in settings of non-mahram interaction.
• Hadith of the Prophet (PBUH): "No man is alone with a woman except that Shaytan is the third among them." (Tirmidhi, 2165)
• This Hadith underscores the importance of boundaries and the need for safeguards.

Balanced Islamic Approach

Islam permits collaboration between genders (e.g., in commerce, education, or public service), as long as:

• Dress is appropriate.
• Speech is respectful.
• Intentions are pure.
• Environment is secure and public.

Table: How Hijab Aligns with Maqasid of Sharia

Sharia Objective (Maqasid)	Hijab's Role	Outcome
Preservation of Dignity	Prevents objectification and protects honor	Self-respect, reduced harassment
Promotion of Morality	Encourages modest behavior and self-control	Uplifted personal and public ethics
Regulation of Gender Relations	Defines boundaries for interaction with non-mahrams	Healthy, respectful societal dynamics
Prevention of Harm (Darar)	Limits emotional or physical harm from unregulated interaction	Social stability and mental wellbeing
Protection of Lineage	Discourages illicit relationships	Preserves family structure and legitimacy

Hijab as an Act of Worship

In Islamic theology, worship ('ibadah) encompasses more than just prayer, fasting, or pilgrimage—it includes any act done sincerely for the sake of Allah, in obedience to His commands. Hijab, therefore, is not only a social or moral obligation but a form of worship. When a Muslim woman chooses to wear the hijab in accordance with Islamic guidelines, she is performing a deliberate act of devotion. This section explains how hijab serves as a means of submitting to Allah's will and cultivating both inner and outer modesty, reinforcing the idea that faith is reflected through action.

Submission to Allah's Will

One of the most fundamental principles of Islam is submission to Allah (Islam itself means submission). The hijab exemplifies this principle, especially when it is observed in environments where it may be socially or emotionally challenging.

Hijab as an Expression of Obedience

• When a Muslim woman wears the hijab in line with Qur'anic instruction and prophetic teachings, she is placing divine command above personal or societal preferences.
• It becomes an act of tawakkul (trust in Allah)—believing that His guidance is for her benefit, even when it defies cultural norms or peer pressure.

Qur'anic Foundation

Surah An-Nur (24:31):

"And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment..."

This command represents a direct instruction from Allah, making obedience to it a form of worship.

Hadith Evidence

The Prophet (PBUH) said:

"Every act of obedience to Allah is a form of worship."

(Reported in al-Bukhari's Adab al-Mufrad)

Why It Matters

1. Sincerity (Ikhlas): Wearing hijab for the sake of Allah distinguishes it from cultural or familial practices.
2. Reward in the Hereafter: Acts done with sincere intention carry spiritual reward even if they're difficult in this life.
3. Perseverance through Trials: Wearing hijab despite criticism or discrimination reflects strong faith and endurance.

Example

A woman in a secular society choosing to wear the hijab despite workplace pressure or public scrutiny is performing a daily act of resistance and worship through obedience.

Internal and External Modesty

Islam defines modesty (haya') as a comprehensive concept that governs both the inner state (heart, intention, thoughts) and the outer behavior (speech, dress, actions). Hijab is one visible sign of modesty, but its effectiveness depends on being paired with internal sincerity and humility.

Understanding External Modesty

• Involves appropriate dress according to Qur'anic guidelines—loose, opaque clothing that covers the body except for what has been exempted (face and hands according to majority opinion).
• Requires modest speech and controlled gaze, particularly in mixed-gender settings.
• Reflects a public commitment to Islamic values.

Understanding Internal Modesty

• Begins with taqwa (God-consciousness), motivating the believer to act in accordance with divine will.
• Includes humility, self-awareness, and avoiding vanity or arrogance about one's appearance—even in hijab.
• Expresses itself through respectful behavior, truthfulness, and clean intentions in dealing with others.

Balanced Approach

• A woman wearing hijab should not only dress modestly but also carry herself with dignity, avoiding behaviors that contradict the spirit of modesty.
• Hijab is most meaningful when it flows from the heart outward, not the other way around.

Scholarly View

• Imam Nawawi said: "Modesty is part of faith. The greater the modesty, the stronger the faith."
• Ibn Taymiyyah emphasized that modesty must stem from within and manifest outwardly in actions and attire.

Table: Worship, Modesty & Hijab

Aspect	Hijab's Function	Impact on Faith
Obedience to Allah	Following Qur'anic and Hadith commands	Transforms daily wear into worship
Sincerity (Ikhlas)	Wearing hijab purely for Allah's sake	Earns reward, strengthens spiritual intent
External Modesty	Modest dress, speech, gaze	Demonstrates public commitment to Islam
Internal Modesty	Humility, taqwa, good behavior	Nurtures genuine modesty and self-awareness
Daily Worship	Wearing hijab despite challenges	Consistent act of devotion

Modern Challenges and Misconceptions

In today's diverse global context, the hijab has become a subject of intense debate—both within and outside the Muslim community. While many see it as a personal and religious obligation, others view it through cultural, political, or ideological lenses. This has led to numerous misconceptions, controversies, and challenges, particularly for Muslim women living in multicultural or non-Muslim societies. In this section, we will address the distinction between cultural and religious expressions of hijab, and explore how Islamic thought responds to feminist critiques in a balanced and informed manner.

Cultural Hijab vs Religious Hijab

One of the most common modern misconceptions about hijab is the assumption that all forms of covering are driven purely by culture. While some traditions do influence style and practice, it is essential to differentiate between what Islam commands and what culture adds.

Understanding Cultural Influences

• In some regions, hijab is tied to ethnic or tribal norms, often enforced by families or communities without proper Islamic context.
• Styles vary widely—from colorful African wraps to plain black abayas in the Gulf, to modern turbans or layered scarves in urban cities.
• Some women may wear the hijab as a symbol of identity or family honor, not as a religious act.

Understanding the Religious Mandate

• The religious hijab is based on the command from Allah in the Qur'an, such as in Surah An-Nur (24:31) and Surah Al-Ahzab (33:59).
• It includes specific guidelines: covering the entire body except face and hands (according to majority opinion), loose-fitting, opaque clothing, and avoidance of excessive adornment.
• The intention (niyyah) behind wearing it is key—it must be worn for the sake of Allah, not to conform to society.

Consequences of Confusing the Two

1. Misjudgment: Some reject hijab altogether, assuming it's just a cultural construct with no religious foundation.
2. Pressure: In some societies, women feel forced to wear or remove hijab based on cultural expectations, not religious conviction.
3. Stereotyping: Media often conflates traditional garments with Islamic law, leading to misrepresentation.

Clarification from Scholars

• Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen stated: "The obligation of hijab is not tied to tradition but to divine command."
• Dr. Yasir Qadhi explains that Islam allows cultural flexibility in style, but not in the core conditions of hijab.

Feminist Critiques and Islamic Answers

Hijab is often discussed in feminist circles—sometimes as a tool of oppression, and sometimes as a symbol of empowerment. These differing views reflect wider conversations about autonomy, gender roles, and freedom.

Common Feminist Critiques

1. Hijab is imposed: Critics argue that women are forced to wear hijab by patriarchal systems or male authority.
2. Hijab limits freedom: It is seen as restricting women's ability to express themselves or participate equally in society.
3. Hijab reinforces gender inequality: Some claim it places the burden of modesty solely on women.

Islamic Responses

Hijab as a Choice of Devotion:

• Islamically, hijab is a personal obligation to Allah, not men.
• When worn willingly, it is a sign of strength and commitment, not submission to culture or family.
• Women across the world choose to wear hijab despite political bans or social pressure—this reflects agency, not oppression.

Equality in Modesty:

• The Qur'an commands both men and women to observe modesty. "Tell the believing men to lower their gaze…" (Surah An-Nur, 24:30)
• Modesty is a mutual value, though hijab takes a different physical form for women.

Freedom through Obedience:

• From an Islamic perspective, true liberation lies in obeying the Creator, not conforming to societal expectations.
• Many Muslim women express that hijab frees them from being judged for their looks, allowing them to be valued for intellect and ethics.

Muslim Feminist Voices

• Amina Wadud argues that the hijab is meaningful when chosen as part of a personal faith journey, rather than imposed by others.
• Leila Ahmed, in Women and Gender in Islam, notes that veiling has meant different things in different contexts—resistance, identity, or piety.

Table: Cultural vs Religious Hijab & Feminist Concerns

Misconception or Challenge	Clarification in Islam	Resulting Understanding
Hijab is cultural	Rooted in clear Qur'anic guidance, not just tradition	Hijab is a religious duty with flexible cultural expression
Hijab is forced	Islam commands hijab but condemns coercion	Personal conviction is essential for valid worship
Hijab limits freedom	Modesty is a source of dignity, not restriction	Freedom is redefined as obedience to Allah
Men are not held to modesty	Qur'an equally commands men to lower gaze and dress properly	Modesty is a mutual responsibility
Hijab equals inequality	Modesty standards differ by gender but serve the same purpose	Equality in value, difference in roles

FAQs – Academic and General Questions on Hijab

To conclude this educational guide, here are some of the most frequently asked questions about hijab—gathered from both scholarly circles and everyday inquiries. These answers are designed to provide clarity, reference core Islamic sources, and respect diverse contexts across the Muslim world. Whether you are exploring the topic academically or personally, this section addresses the most pressing and commonly misunderstood issues about hijab.

Is hijab a cultural or religious obligation?

Hijab is a religious obligation, not merely a cultural tradition. While styles of hijab can reflect local customs, the foundation of the obligation comes from the Qur'an and Sunnah. Verses such as Surah An-Nur (24:31) and Surah Al-Ahzab (33:59) clearly instruct believing women to cover certain parts of their bodies in public.

Summary:

• Culture influences appearance, but hijab itself is a divine mandate.
• Wearing hijab with the right intention is a form of worship.

What are the scriptural proofs for hijab?

The obligation of hijab is based on several Qur'anic verses and Hadiths:

Surah An-Nur (24:31)

"...And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their private parts and not to show their adornment…"

Surah Al-Ahzab (33:59)

"O Prophet, tell your wives and daughters and the believing women to draw their cloaks (jalabib) over themselves…"

Hadith

The Prophet (PBUH) instructed women to wear loose garments and explained the limits of adornment (Abu Dawood, 4104).

Summary:

• The Qur'an explicitly instructs modest dress.
• Hijab includes covering and modest behavior.

How do scholars interpret hijab in different madhahib?

While all four major Sunni schools of thought (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali) agree on the obligation of hijab, they differ slightly in details:

Madhhab	What Must Be Covered	Face & Hands	Niqaab Required?
Hanafi	Entire body	Face & hands may remain uncovered	No (not wajib)
Maliki	Entire body	Face & hands may remain uncovered	No
Shafi'i	Entire body	Some say hands/face may be shown, others require covering	Disputed
Hanbali	Entire body	Preferable to cover face and hands	Yes (stricter view)

Summary:

• All madhahib affirm hijab is fard (obligatory).
• Niqab is optional according to majority but encouraged in certain contexts.

What if wearing hijab puts me in danger?

In Islamic jurisprudence, preservation of life takes precedence. If a Muslim woman is living in an environment where hijab puts her in physical danger (e.g., threats, violence, hate crimes), scholars permit her to remove or adjust her hijab based on necessity.

Example: A woman in a country where hijab is legally banned or attacked may reduce visibility (e.g., wear a hat or hoodie) if done with the intention of modesty and fear of harm.

Summary:

• Islam does not demand self-harm.
• Consult with a trusted scholar for specific cases of hardship.

Is niqab (face veil) also mandatory?

Scholars differ on the ruling of niqab:

• Majority opinion (Hanafi, Maliki): Niqab is not mandatory but highly recommended in environments where a woman may be objectified.
• Hanbali opinion: Niqab is wajib if there is risk of fitnah or unnecessary male attention.
• Shafi'i opinion: There is a strong recommendation for niqab, but it is not universally required.

Summary:

• Niqab is not a universal obligation.
• It may become required based on context and intent.

How does hijab relate to male modesty?

Islam emphasizes modesty for both men and women. Men are also commanded to:

• Lower their gaze (Surah An-Nur, 24:30).
• Dress modestly (covering from navel to knee is the minimum).
• Avoid vanity and inappropriate speech.

However, hijab in the form of clothing is specifically legislated for women due to differences in public interaction, physical adornment, and traditional dress codes.

Summary:

• Modesty is a two-way value in Islam.
• Hijab is one part of a broader ethic shared by both genders.

Does hijab hinder women's rights or promote them?

From an Islamic perspective, hijab promotes women's rights by:

• Protecting personal privacy.
• Allowing women to define how they are perceived.
• Shifting attention away from physical appearance toward intellect and character.

Many Muslim women assert that hijab gives them power over their own bodies and spaces, rather than submitting to objectifying beauty standards.

Summary:

• Hijab is empowerment when worn by choice.
• It protects dignity and redefines public identity.

Hijab FAQs at a Glance

Question	Short Answer	Islamic Basis
Is hijab religious or cultural?	Religious obligation	Surah An-Nur, 24:31; Surah Al-Ahzab, 33:59
Scriptural proofs?	Yes, clear Qur'an verses and Hadith	Qur'anic commands, Abu Dawood 4104
Do scholars agree on hijab?	Yes, with minor differences	All four madhahib confirm obligation
What if I'm in danger?	Safety comes first	Principle of preserving life
Is niqab mandatory?	Disputed; mostly recommended	Based on context and madhhab
Do men have modesty rules?	Yes, equally required	Surah An-Nur, 24:30
Does hijab oppress women?	No, it empowers when chosen	Intent and context are key

Conclusion: Understanding the Deeper Meaning Behind Hijab

Hijab in Islam is not a mere piece of cloth nor a cultural symbol—it is a multifaceted command rooted in divine revelation, moral purpose, and individual devotion. Through examining its historical context, legal foundations, ethical goals, and contemporary challenges, it becomes clear that hijab serves far more than a social function. It is a deliberate act of submission to Allah, a means of preserving personal dignity, and a reflection of internal modesty.

For Muslim women who wear the hijab, it is an everyday commitment—often carried out with patience, confidence, and spiritual strength. Whether in a supportive environment or facing external pressures, the choice to uphold the hijab is deeply personal and firmly grounded in faith. It aligns with the maqasid ash-shariah—preserving morality, protecting identity, and fostering a society based on respect and accountability.

Moreover, hijab is not an isolated rule imposed on women while men remain free of expectations. Islam upholds modesty as a shared ethic, commanding both men and women to lower their gaze, behave with integrity, and preserve their honor. The hijab simply represents one part of this broader vision of decency and mutual respect.

In our modern world, where identity, autonomy, and belief systems often collide, understanding hijab from an Islamic perspective allows for a more informed and respectful discourse. It is neither a relic of the past nor a tool of oppression—it is a meaningful act of worship chosen by millions of women as an expression of devotion, conviction, and freedom on their own terms. To explore the core reasoning further, see: Why Does Allah Want Hijab?

Let us move beyond stereotypes and shallow critiques and approach hijab with the academic curiosity and respect it deserves. When grounded in knowledge and sincerity, hijab becomes not just a religious command, but a powerful symbol of strength, clarity, and purpose.

Akhmad Syafiuddin An expert in Islamic discourse and law, and a graduate of Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.

Share :